Thursday, March 22, 2018

Hypocrisy: The Leaven of the Pharisees (Matthew 16:5-12)


In our study of Matthew, we have repeatedly noticed that Jesus does not just make random statements.  Matthew has deliberately arranged his historical narrative concerning Jesus’ ministry in such a way that we can view certain themes that Matthew found most compelling concerning the life and mission of the Messiah.  He has done this most effectively through the record of His interaction with the people, with their leaders and with His followers.

In our last study, we saw how the leaders – the Pharisees and Sadducees – like everyone – felt fairly confident in their ability to discern and respond to issues in the physical realm.  Jesus used the example of their ability to discern the weather from simple observations of the sky.  However, they were unable to discern “the signs of the times.”  They had dismissed the gospel of the kingdom that both John the Baptist and the Messiah had proclaimed saying, ‘Repent for the kingdom of God is within reach.’  Both of these divinely appointed spokesmen saw their message being embraced in the physical realm but rejected in the spiritual realm.  This was in large part due to the religious leaders being blind guides who both Jesus and John called ‘hypocrites’ – a term we need to investigate in the way that Jesus used it.  The result of their ‘hypocrisy’ was that they tended to focus on externals at the expense of the root problem which was in the heart.  Thus, there was no repentance—not even a recognition of the depth of the problem.  It was a fatal inability for them. 

We saw how the sign of Jonah was the only external sign they would get—and they would reject it.  Nineveh repented and yet God’s own chosen people refused to listen to the warning.

So now in verses 5-12 of chapter 16, Jesus takes his disciples back across the Sea of Galilee to Dalmanutha (which means harbor in Aramaic)—the port of the city of Magadan.  They apparently left in such a hurry that the disciples forgot to purchase enough bread for the trip.  So, they began arguing about whose fault it was.

Matthew reports that Jesus made a rather pointed observation and warning.  “Beware the leaven of the Pharisees.”  Now, the disciples wrongly but naturally connected His comment with their failure to buy enough bread since leaven is a crucial ingredient in making bread.  Perhaps, Jesus’ comment came across as warning them not to buy bread from the Pharisees.  They were totally focused on the fact they had no bread and now it looked like Jesus didn’t want them buying bread from outsiders. (This can be a problem for us, too.  As we spend time in the Word, it is quite tempting to attempt to relate the passage of Scripture to our immediate felt needs instead of asking for God to open our eyes to what He is trying to show us.)

But Jesus used the opportunity to help them learn from the events of the past few weeks.  “Don’t you get it, guys?  Have you forgotten how God supplied our daily bread even miraculously with the feeding of the 5000 and then the 4000.  Remember all the leftovers from those events?” 

Then He repeated His enigmatic warning: “Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees.”  What kind of bread had the Pharisees supplied?  Not bread but leaven—an ingredient known for its ability to spread throughout the whole batch of dough and make it rise and when baked the flour has been transformed from a powder into bread.”  What is this ingredient that spreads and transforms that was propagated by the Pharisees?  Jesus had His words and works that presented the Word of God to repent for the kingdom of God is within reach.  The Pharisees had their words and works also. 

Jesus revealed that their words and works needed repentance—change—because they dealt with the externals only and even that was corrupt when examined in the light of Scripture.  So, to repeat the earlier assertion, their words and works were labeled by both John and Jesus as ‘hypocrisy.’  What exactly does Jesus mean by this?

In today’s usage, a hypocrite is one whose words do not match his works.  But this is not the whole picture as it is used in the New Testament.  In Greek, a hypocrite was the term used for orators and poetry readers and actors.  These were people who were attempting to give ‘an answer’ to a situation—which is the root meaning of ‘hypocrite’.  Eventually, its use for actors gave it a figurative emphasis on someone who was playacting.  But among the Greek speaking Jews, it was used to describe those who were godless despite a polished exterior.

In Jesus’ day, the Pharisees were attempting to give their ‘answer’—their solution—to the problem of estrangement from God.  Their solution—their leaven—their teaching—was to polish the exterior.  Or, as Jesus put it later, ‘whitewash the mausoleum.’  But how do you ‘bring forth fruit in keeping with righteousness’ (as John the Baptist put it), when the condition of the heart was wicked (as Jesus had just pointed out)? 

The Pharisees resisted Jesus message that the interior world needed total transformation. It conflicted with their message, their teaching, their leaven, that the physical world was where the problem lay.  And the disciples’ argument about bread was a subtle shift in their understanding of ‘the answer.’  Jesus uses the incident to point out that ‘the answer’ is not to be found in our efforts surrounding the physical world.  We don’t ignore it, because Jesus did use real bread in the physical world to provide for a miracle feast—twice.  But, conflict in the physical world stems from unresolved issues in the unseen world of the heart.  In this case, a lack of faith and trust in their Leader.  This lack of faith was due to a spirit of self-reliance in the outer world—a whiff of the leaven of the Pharisees.

How is this focus on the exterior world affecting our hearts today?  I am speaking of believers.  Who or what are we looking at to save us, to sustain us, to provide for us?  I am afraid that even among believers there are differing visions of ’the answer’ to this need—differences that are causing divisions and bitterness between brothers and sisters in some quarters and even worse bitterness among some against the God Who provided a Savior—because their own expectations were not met in this outer world.

In Biblical terms, hypocrisy is ultimately a focus on the physical realm to solve a spiritual problem.  Jesus says, ‘Beware the leaven of the Pharisees.’  This is a leaven that spreads and affects everyone whom it contacts.

© 2018 Eric Thimell

No comments: